Declining immigration exacerbating tight job market

For several years now, the US has been through a much talked-about labor shortage. Initially, this could be attributed to the temporarily reduced workforce caused by COVID. But the labor shortage doesn’t seem to be letting up, and long-standing trends indicate it won’t. According to the National Law Review, three primary reasons are likely causing this: declining birth rates, an aging population, and low immigration. While pro-family policies and incentives can boost birth rates, immigration is a more reliable driver of population growth, according to one policy expert that the National Law Review spoke to. With immigration on a recent decline, we take a look at how it’s impacting the job market.

Immigration drops along with US population growth
While US population growth has been in decline for decades, immigration has generally increased year over year. In 2019, 462,422 legal permanent residents arrived from abroad, according to the US State Department. In 2020, that number dropped to 263,849, then again to 153,620 in 2021. Such staggering decreases haven’t been seen in decades, and considering the continuing decreases in birth rates, don’t bode well for the job market.

Why does immigration impact the job market so much?
While immigration has been politicized heavily, data shows that legal immigration is a boon to the US economy. Labor participation among immigrants is higher than the general population, and they fill roles important to the economy, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Those without a college degree are shown to occupy roles that employers otherwise find hard to fill, increasing the economy’s ability to produce what’s needed and meet consumer demand – the importance of which is becoming increasingly more important as the US continues to see supply chain shortages. And an abundance of jobs needing highly educated individuals demonstrates the continued need for immigration. For example, as of December 2021, there were more than 1.5 million open computer occupations, Forbes reports.

What role does immigration play in The Great Resignation?
While many disagree over what triggered The Great Resignation (and what is causing it to continue), it's hard to argue with the evidence that the dramatic drop in immigration is exacerbating it. As economists have noted, immigration is generally a fuel source for the economy, the job market especially. Without that influx of individuals, the job market becomes even tighter. While The Great Resignation rages on and people continue leaving their jobs, the lack of immigrant labor means fewer options for employers. It’s a cycle that perpetuates the continuing shortage of labor.

Where does immigration (and the job market) go in 2022?
As with any change in government administration, we’ll likely see changes in many aspects of the economy. According to Forbes, 5 changes coming in 2022 are expected to impact immigration:

  • H1-B work visas will change a bit to encourage incoming high-earner immigration

  • Expedited processing for certain employment-based visas will be expanded

  • Filing fees are expected to increase (helping to stabilize USCIS finances)

  • As COVID Consulate closures ease, applications will be processed more quickly

  • Passage of a bill to allow green cards for investors of the EB-5 program is expected

While some of these are not yet official, experts anticipate most or all to come about in 2022.

Immigration is a complex issue, made even more so by how it impacts the job market and economy. Will a boost in immigration help alleviate the labor shortage? It's difficult to say, but with The Great Resignation still going strong, it can only help.

More from Hire Insights

Connect with us on social media

Get Started

Click to get started with JobTarget

Contact Us
© 2022 JobTarget ®