Garage Underwriting Supervisor in New York at Jobgether

New
Jobgether
New York, 10455, United States
Posted on
New job! Apply early to increase your chances of getting hired.

Job Description

Garage Underwriting Supervisor

This position is listed on behalf of a partner company, who manages all applications and next steps. Our partner is looking for an Underwriting Supervisor based in the United States.

Overview:

We are seeking an experienced Underwriting Supervisor to lead and coordinate a team of underwriters across multiple jurisdictions within a property and casualty insurance environment. In this role, you will oversee underwriting operations, ensuring high-quality decisions, accurate work, and consistent productivity while supporting business profitability. You will serve as a key resource for technical guidance, agent relationships, and complex underwriting matters. Through effective workflow management, performance monitoring, and staff development, you will help strengthen team capabilities and service delivery. You will also collaborate with internal departments and external partners to improve processes and identify new business opportunities. This role combines people leadership, technical underwriting expertise, and relationship management, with some regional travel required.

Accountabilities:

As Underwriting Supervisor, you will oversee daily team operations, maintain underwriting standards, and ensure that business objectives are achieved. You will also provide guidance to employees and external partners while supporting continuous improvement across the unit. Your responsibilities will include:

  • Supervise, coordinate, and monitor the activities and performance of an underwriting team across multiple jurisdictions, ensuring accurate, high-quality work and strong production levels.

  • Schedule, prioritize, and distribute workloads to maintain efficient operations and meet deadlines.

  • Provide technical guidance and expertise to underwriters, agents, and policyholders.

  • Act as a liaison with other supervisors, branches, and corporate departments to coordinate activities and resolve operational issues.

  • Conduct agency visits in accordance with established standards.

  • Recommend, plan, organize, and implement procedural improvements to enhance workflow and underwriting performance.

  • Stay informed about changes affecting underwriting operations and developments across the insurance industry.

  • Manage team production and profitability in line with established budgets and business objectives.

  • Mediate and resolve issues involving agents, insured parties, and internal departments.

  • Provide testimony in court or participate in depositions when required in connection with claims or coverage matters.

  • Develop and use management reports to monitor individual and team performance and identify opportunities for improvement.

  • Travel to regional offices, existing agents, and prospective agents to strengthen relationships, promote service center capabilities, and explore business opportunities. Travel is expected to represent approximately 5%–15% of working time.

  • Oversee employee training and professional development, provide ongoing performance feedback, and make personnel recommendations to ensure effective team management.

Requirements:

The ideal candidate will have a strong technical underwriting background, proven experience in insurance operations, and the leadership skills needed to manage a geographically distributed team. Strong analytical abilities, communication skills, and a commitment to quality and productivity are essential.

  • At least 7 years of underwriting experience.

  • Broad technical knowledge of underwriting principles and practices.

  • Strong verbal and written communication skills.

  • Good analytical and problem-solving abilities.

  • Proficiency in Microsoft Word, Excel, and Outlook.

  • College degree preferred.

  • 3–4 years of experience in rating, inspections, and claims preferred.

  • Ability to guide and develop underwriting professionals while maintaining high operational standards.

  • Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage competing priorities and deadlines.

  • Ability to build effective working relationships with agents, policyholders, and internal stakeholders.

Benefits:

  • Annual base salary: $96,000–$125,000, depending on geographic location, qualifications, experience, skills, performance, and business needs.

  • Eligibility for an incentive plan.

  • Comprehensive healthcare plans.

  • Retirement savings plan with employer matching contributions.

  • Discounted employee stock purchase program.

  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs.

  • 20 days of paid time off.

  • Additional benefits designed to support employees' health, financial well-being, and work-life balance.

How Jobgether works:
We use an AI-powered matching process to ensure your application is reviewed quickly, objectively, and fairly against the role's core requirements. Our system identifies the top-fitting candidates, and this shortlist is then shared directly with the hiring company. The final decision and next steps (interviews, assessments) are managed by their internal team.
We appreciate your interest and wish you the best!
Data Privacy Notice: By submitting your application, you acknowledge that Jobgether will process your personal data to evaluate your candidacy and share relevant information with the hiring employer. This processing is based on legitimate interest and pre-contractual measures under applicable data protection laws (including GDPR). You may exercise your rights (access, rectification, erasure, objection) at any time.
#LI-CL1

Explore Related Opportunities

Job Location

New York, 10455, United States

Frequently asked questions about this position

Apply For This Position

Apply Now