Nonprofit / philanthropy / community programs Evaluator in New York at Jobgether

This position is listed on behalf of a partner company, who manages all applications and next steps. Our partner is looking for a Nonprofit / Philanthropy / Community Programs Evaluator based in the United States.

This remote, hourly opportunity is designed for experienced professionals with deep expertise in nonprofit, philanthropy, or community-based programs.
You’ll apply your real-world knowledge to evaluate AI-generated documents, spreadsheets, presentations, and other work products.
The role focuses on assessing outputs for accuracy, rigor, relevance, and alignment with professional practices in the social-impact sector.
You’ll identify gaps, factual issues, and weaknesses that could reduce the quality or effectiveness of AI-generated materials.
Your structured feedback will help improve how AI understands and supports nonprofit and community-focused work.
The engagement is flexible and fully remote, with projects that can be completed on your own schedule.
You’ll work asynchronously with a research team while contributing specialized expertise to the development of AI systems.

• Evaluate AI-generated documents, spreadsheets, slide decks, and other artifacts against established nonprofit, philanthropy, and community-program quality rubrics.
• Assess outputs for factual accuracy, relevance, rigor, clarity, and alignment with real-world sector practices.
• Identify factual, analytical, aesthetic, structural, and presentation-related errors or omissions.
• Apply professional judgment to determine whether AI-generated recommendations and materials are practical, appropriate, and responsive to community or organizational needs.
• Review materials from the perspective of nonprofit operations, philanthropic initiatives, community programs, and social-impact work where applicable.
• Provide clear, structured written feedback explaining identified issues and opportunities for improvement.
• Help distinguish high-quality, contextually appropriate outputs from responses that lack sufficient nuance or domain understanding.
• Collaborate asynchronously with the research team to support consistent evaluation standards and improve AI-generated work.
• Complete assigned projects accurately and within established timelines while avoiding the use of confidential or proprietary information.

• 5+ years of relevant professional experience in nonprofit organizations, philanthropy, foundations, community programs, social-impact initiatives, or closely related fields.
• Strong practical understanding of nonprofit and community-program environments, including their goals, stakeholders, operational considerations, and impact objectives.
• Ability to critically assess professional work products and determine whether they demonstrate sound reasoning, accuracy, and appropriate domain judgment.
• Native or professional fluency in English, with strong written communication skills.
• Highly proficient in Microsoft Office and Google Workspace, particularly Google Slides and/or PowerPoint.
• Strong analytical and critical-thinking skills, with excellent attention to detail.
• Ability to identify factual inaccuracies, contextual gaps, presentation issues, and weaknesses in AI-generated materials.
• Ability to communicate feedback clearly, objectively, and constructively.
• Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage independent work and deadlines in a remote, asynchronous environment.
• Preferred: Advanced degree (Master’s or higher) from a reputable institution or equivalent advanced professional expertise.

• Compensation: $80–$120 per hour.
• Fully remote opportunity for professionals based in the United States.
• Flexible work that can generally be completed on your own schedule.
• Independent contractor engagement.
• Weekly payments through Stripe or Wise based on services rendered.
• Opportunity to apply your nonprofit, philanthropy, or community-program expertise to the development of AI systems.
• Asynchronous collaboration with a research team.
• Projects may be extended, shortened, or concluded early depending on project needs and performance.
• Work does not require access to confidential or proprietary information from any employer, client, or institution.
• Please note: H-1B and STEM OPT candidates cannot be supported for this opportunity.