Case Qualification Supervisor in New York at Jobgether

NewJob Function: Admin/Clerical/Secretarial
Jobgether
New York, 10455, United States
Posted on
New job! Apply early to increase your chances of getting hired.

Job Description

Case Qualification Supervisor

This position is listed on behalf of a partner company, who manages all applications and next steps. Our partner is looking for a Case Qualification Supervisor based in the United States.

The Case Qualification Supervisor will lead a team of specialists responsible for evaluating complex personal injury cases and identifying promising legal opportunities. This role combines hands-on case assessment, team leadership, performance management, and operational improvement within a rapidly growing, fully remote legal environment. You will oversee escalated cases, guide specialists through challenging decisions, and ensure qualification recommendations are accurate, consistent, and timely. Working closely with Intake, Legal, Quality Assurance, and Analytics teams, you will help strengthen processes and improve the overall client experience. This is an opportunity to shape a growing qualification function, develop high-performing teams, and contribute directly to the firm's operational success.

Accountabilities
  • Lead, coach, and develop Case Qualification Specialists through regular one-on-one meetings, case reviews, performance evaluations, and continuous feedback.

  • Serve as the primary escalation point for complex, ambiguous, or exception-based personal injury cases requiring additional investigation and professional judgment.

  • Personally review cases involving unclear liability, serious injuries, commercial entities, government organizations, conflicting information, or other unusual circumstances.

  • Ensure specialists collect, verify, and document all relevant information before recommending whether a case should be accepted, referred, or declined.

  • Determine when additional investigation or attorney guidance is necessary to support appropriate qualification decisions.

  • Monitor key performance indicators, including case volume, turnaround times, pending cases, follow-up activities, decision accuracy, documentation quality, productivity, and client satisfaction.

  • Analyze qualification outcomes, attorney overrides, referral and decline patterns, and missed opportunities to identify trends and operational improvement areas.

  • Review intake calls, questionnaires, and case documentation to identify information gaps and recommend improvements to scripts, workflows, qualification criteria, training materials, and escalation procedures.

  • Collaborate with Intake Operations, Legal, Quality Assurance, Learning and Development, and Analytics teams to improve qualification standards and reduce unnecessary escalations.

  • Ensure prospective clients receive timely, empathetic, and professional communication throughout the qualification process.

  • Promote accountability, critical thinking, curiosity, and sound judgment, empowering specialists to assess each case based on its individual circumstances rather than relying exclusively on predefined scripts or checklists.

  • Drive continuous improvement initiatives that strengthen case evaluation accuracy, operational efficiency, and the overall client experience.

Requirements
  • Strong professional experience in personal injury intake, insurance claims, case evaluation, paralegal services, legal operations, or a closely related field.

  • Solid understanding of personal injury liability, injury severity, case valuation indicators, and the factors involved in determining whether a legal opportunity is viable.

  • Previous experience in a supervisory, team leadership, coaching, or people management position is strongly preferred.

  • Excellent investigative and analytical abilities, with the capacity to evaluate incomplete, inconsistent, or ambiguous information.

  • Demonstrated ability to make well-supported and defensible recommendations while recognizing situations requiring further investigation or attorney involvement.

  • Strong analytical skills and the ability to interpret operational data, identify performance trends, investigate root causes, and recommend practical improvements.

  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to summarize complex case details and communicate recommendations clearly.

  • Strong organizational and prioritization skills, with the ability to manage multiple high-priority cases, competing deadlines, and sensitive client situations.

  • Experience using CRM systems, case management platforms, or contact center technologies.

  • Familiarity with Salesforce and Filevine is preferred.

  • A proactive, solutions-oriented mindset, with the ability to adapt to changing priorities and thrive in a fast-paced, high-growth environment.

  • Strong leadership qualities, including accountability, adaptability, collaboration, professionalism, and a commitment to continuous learning.

Benefits
  • Competitive compensation: Base salary determined by experience, qualifications, and geographic location.

  • Performance incentives: Eligibility for performance-based bonuses.

  • Comprehensive healthcare: Medical, dental, and vision insurance coverage.

  • Retirement planning: 401(k) retirement savings plan with employer matching contributions.

  • Health savings: Health Savings Account (HSA) options.

  • Financial protection: Life insurance and disability coverage.

  • Work-life balance: Paid time off and parental leave.

  • Remote flexibility: Fully remote, full-time employment within the United States.

  • Career development: Opportunity to lead and develop a growing team within an expanding legal operations environment.

  • Meaningful impact: Help improve access to legal services by strengthening how personal injury cases are evaluated and qualified.

How Jobgether works:
We use an AI-powered matching process to ensure your application is reviewed quickly, objectively, and fairly against the role's core requirements. Our system identifies the top-fitting candidates, and this shortlist is then shared directly with the hiring company. The final decision and next steps (interviews, assessments) are managed by their internal team.
We appreciate your interest and wish you the best!
Data Privacy Notice: By submitting your application, you acknowledge that Jobgether will process your personal data to evaluate your candidacy and share relevant information with the hiring employer. This processing is based on legitimate interest and pre-contractual measures under applicable data protection laws (including GDPR). You may exercise your rights (access, rectification, erasure, objection) at any time.
#LI-CL1

Explore Related Opportunities

Job Location

New York, 10455, United States

Frequently asked questions about this position

Apply For This Position

Apply Now